Other formats

    Adobe Portable Document Format file (facsimile images)   TEI XML file   ePub eBook file  

Connect

    mail icontwitter iconBlogspot iconrss icon

Immediate report of Victoria University of Wellington Antarctic Expedition 1989-90: VUWAE 34

WEST ANTARCTIC VOLCANO EXPLORATION (WAVE) K048

page 72

WEST ANTARCTIC VOLCANO EXPLORATION (WAVE) K048

Aims

The aim and objectives of the WAVE programme are a comprehensive study of Cenozoic volcanism in West Antarctica. The project includes geochronological, volcanological, petrological and geochemical studies of volcanic rocks and the lithospheric xenoliths canted to the surface by volcanic processes. The programme involved field mapping, section measuring and sampling of rocks.

Planning

Logistic planning for the field season was undertaken by Gamble, Smellie (BAS), McIntosh and Panter (NSF) at the Congress of the International Association of Volcanology and Chemistry of the Earth's Interior held in Santa Fe, New Mexico during June 1989. There, a schedule for fieldwork during the 1989/90 season was formulated. A Put-in site was agreed upon and dates for flights arranged.

Atkinson and Gamble had the opportunity to undertake additional planning when they met at the Tekapo orientation meeting. We two are of the opinion that the Tekapo orientation meeting is a worthwhile and valuable exercise. A first, and perhaps only opportunity for all participants in the NZARP to meet and an opportunity to brush up on many skills and techniques.

Additional comments are contained in the Appendix prepared by Bill Atkinson in consultation with myself and other party members.

Cargo

Geological hammers were transported to Antarctica as a part of the VUWAE shipment. No excess baggage was carried to or from Scott Base.

Personnel

Members of K - 048 for the 1990/91 season to Marie Byrd Land, Executive Committee Range were as follows:
1)John Gamble, Dept. of Geology, Victoria University of Wellington, PO Box 600, Wellington.
2)Bill Atkinson, 173, McKenzie Drive, Twizel.
3)John Smellie, British Antarctic Survey, Madingley Road, Cambridge, U.K.
4)Chris Griffiths, British Antarctic Survey, Madingley Road, Cambridge, U.K.

See also comments in Appendix 1 (under Employment selection).

Preparations for the Field

Atkinson (K-048) together with Mc Intosh and Panter (S-081B) left New Zealand for the ice on or around 13th November 1989. Once there, Atkinson proceeded to organise field equipment at Scott Base. McIntosh and Panter departed for Mt. Erebus to assist with the S-081B programme.

Gamble, Smellie and Griffiths (K-048) departed NZ on 21 November 1989 following several days of delay in Christchurch.

Gamble, Smellie and Panter on arrival in Antarctica assisted Atkinson to prepare field equipment and rations for the expedition. Gamble, being familiar with procedures of the Berg Field Centre (BFC) was able to coordinate with McMurdo and BFC staff to arrange Hercules logistics and occasional transfer of field materials to Scott Base for checking and repair.

page 73

We carried out our own survival and crevasse extraction exercises on the ice fall north of Scott Base. We tested skidoos, sledges and towing rigs on a number of shake down trips along Hut Point Peninsula.

Additional details are contained in Appendix 1.

Field Transport

Detailed comments on transportation are contained in Appendix 1 relating to operation and effectiveness of skidoos and air operations. However, at this point we must emphasise that surely something can be done to increase the efficiency and flexibility of Hercules air operations. In MBL the weather experienced by our group was marginal to flying for most of the time. Windows of good weather lasted for relatively short periods, generally 12 hours at most.

Event Diary

Daily movements and field operations are detailed in Appendix 2 which also provides observations on weather conditions experienced in the field.

Event Map

Appendix 3 is a map of vehicle routes, put-in and pick-up sites and major camp sites during the expedition to Executive Committee Range.

Weather

Full details are in Appendix 2. A general impression of weather conditions in MBL was of cloudy, overcast conditions with rare brilliantly clear periods. Prevailing winds were either northerly or southerly.

Accidents

No accidents happened in the field although J Gamble aggravated an old ankle injury when loading field gear at Mc Murdo. The injury proved somewhat painful when cramponing on steep slopes but provided it was kept strapped up it did not affect the groups ability to function.

Field Equipment

Detailed comments are in Appendix 1. These comments were compiled after discussion with all members of K-048 and S-081B.

Radio Communications

The party used American supplied radios and found communications with Scott Base and McMurdo to be generally good. Further comments are contained in Appendix 1 and attention is drawn to the details of the hand held radios which were extensively used in the field.

Environmental Impact

All human waste was buried and metallic waste and non burnable materials (plastics) were returned to McMurdo for disposal.

page 74

Appendix 1: Field Leaders Report - Bin Atkinson
K048: EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE RANGE, MARIE BYRD LAND 1989/90

PERSONNEL
Bill McIntosh (Principal Investigator, Geologist) USA
Kurt Panter (Geologist) USA
John Smellie (Geologist) UK
Chris Griffith (Field Leader) UK
John Gamble (Geologist) NZ
Bill Atkinson (Field Leader) NZ
LOCALITY

Executive Committee Range, western Marie Byrd Land, Antarctica. Isolated range of extinct volcanic cones. Latitude 126°W 77°S to 4181 m /13,713ft altitude.

TIMETABLE

Originally planned for two months in the field, this event was held at Scott Base for 40 days waiting for air transport. The event return to Scott Base was also delayed five days. The period in the research area (December 23 - January 24) allowed only a shortened programme to be undertaken.

REPORT

This report is directed towards comment on NZARP organisation, selection and training procedures, field equipment, transport, logistics, communications and safety. The geological studies will be published in the academic journals by the geology specialists.

Notes listed as "minor" are those I consider to be matters of personal choice, unlikely to have a major impact on future events. They are included for consideration by Field Leaders involved in the detail of planning remote field events. "Major" comments are those I believe may contribute further to comfort, utility or safety.

EMPLOYMENT SELECTION

In the main, the selection process for 1989/90 worked well, judging from the atmosphere at Scott Base, the ability and cooperation of DSIR staff at Tekapo and Scott Base, and the high level of experience evident in people chosen for the field events.

K048′s composition as an international event meant only the two NZ members were directly responsible to, and chosen by, Antarctic Division, DSIR. BAS and NSF were each involved in the selection and funding of their own representatives. I was very happy with the company and experience of all our team members during the summer.

page 75
TEKAPO TRAINING

There is a great deal of value in the Tekapo Training, both because of the opportunity it offers for administrative, logistic technical and field staff to spend time together preseason, and for the venue to pass on to "first-timers" the experience of previous events.

I am personally pleased to see that scientific presentations have been de-emphasised over the years, as I have found many of them too over-long, poorly structured and lacking in good audio-visual support. In a word, boring!

PRE-EVENT ORGANISATION

Due to the very high level of experience within K048 and the assistance of Scott Base staff, pre-event organisation was virtually painless, and accomplished in the time available at Scott Base.

On the downside, my request for a technical manual on the Alpine skidoo was first made at Tekapo and followed up by later contact with Antarctic Division, Christchurch but never produced any result. The lead-time for technical information is perhaps longer than that available to field staff selected just prior to Tekapo.

FIELD EQUIPMENT/STORE

K048 received a lot of willing assistance and courtesy from Doug, John and Willy at Scott Base. Only the smaller items were required from Ant. Div. as the McMurdo BFC were supplying the eight sledges for the event.

Major comments: we used handheld radios extensively in the field, with US solar cells to recharge batteries. I feel that the greater range, speed and reliability of the new Alpine II skidoo will encourage everyday use of handheld radios. The Yuasa FT23 is one model of handheld that I have used on Himalayan expeditions in Pakistan and Nepal. It is small, light, reliable and (relatively) cheap. It can use battery packs of AAA cells, of AA cells, or a rechargeable NiCad version.

Minor points:
1.The NZ bread is greatly superior to the US supply, but good items from the BFC events include tortillas, hotdogs, American pancake mix and maple syrup.
2.The BFC teflon non-stick fry pan and coffee percolator are very good.
3.A "jaffle-iron" (toasted sandwich utensil) would be worth bringing as a personal item for NZ.
4.The large, thick foam mat is a very comfortable alternative to several (smaller) karrimats.
5.The Met. Service daily weather notebook (Met. 807 3rd ed. 1989) lasts 30 days per copy and is easy to use.page 76
6.I would prefer a tube tent door twice the height of the current model.
7.Some of the NZ cheese and chocolate slipped through the system and arrived in the field past expiry date.
8.Field leaders should be aware that NZ primus-priming "meta tabs" will be treated with deep suspicion if presented openly to the US cargo-packing facility. They refused to allow our supply to fly on the "put-in" aircraft, and we had to adopt alternative strategies.
SURVIVAL TRAINING

In consultation with the Survival School Leader (Charlie Hobbs) and the Operations Manager (Don Hammond) we arranged our own programme for 89/90. I assisted as a temporary instructor for survival school on some courses by request.

FIELD EQUIPMENT

Sledges were provided by the US BFC facility. We put handlebars on three of the eight.

Major recommendation: I have felt for some time that the NZ tank system has its good points (can be detached and used as tent floor) but that it is not long enough. Too much time is spent tying items individually fore and aft of the NZ version. The US tank is full-length with ends as well as sides to the canvas "well". But not detachable. I would like to trial-run a detachable, full-length tank with the complete canvas well.

SNOW-MOBILES

We used three US Bombardier Alpine I skidoos.

SKIDOO ID OPERATORS KM READING BEGINNING SEASON KM TOTAL SEASON
# 1727 McIntosh/Panter 2801 850
# 1794 Gamble/Atkinson 4579 882
# 1791 Smellie/Griffith 3832 873

All our operators were experienced in the use of snow-mobiles, and Bill McIntosh is a particularly skilled mechanic. A wide variety of spares and tools were taken, but very little was used. There were no major breakdowns, and only minor maintenance. Quite a few changes were made to jet size and needle position in the carburettors to maximise power on the days we were gaining or losing a lot of altitude. Travel ranged from 6000′ – 13000′. The #250 jet was standard, with #240 and #230 sizes used as replacement with increases in altitude. Power, speed and spark plug colour were used to evaluate carburettor performance.

page 77

I recommend the Bombardier carburettor tool kit (P/N 404 1120 00) and the High Altitude Technical Data booklet (P/N 480 1208 00) be taken for the Alpine S03 model. There is a High Altitude Kit (P/N 881 7253 001) available for the Alpine II, but I do not know if it contains tools, information or both.

Fuel consumption overall was 1/3 less than usual at 8.8 km/gal or 5.4 miles/gal. (The gallon referred to is the US gallon). We used the manufacturer's recommended 1:50 oil/gasoline radio, which turns out to be one 12oz beer can of oil to one jerrycan of fuel. First you have to empty the beer can of beer!!

Fuel was transported in 55 gallon drums, which are heavy and hard to handle. I recommend equivalent volume of 12 gallon drums. We took 18 jerrycans, and filled these from the drums for daily use.

Some form of ear protection is recommended.

LOGISTICS

Logistics into the field are properly the concern of the US Navy and the Scott Base Operations officer and the SENZREP. Navy scheduling is not yet flexible enough for areas such as Marie Byrd Land, which has many short periods of weather suitable for field landings, but an overall pattern of low cloud, flat lighting and snowfall. We are, however, appreciative of the efforts that were made, and particularly thankful to those who managed to reinstate K048/SO81B at the last minute after 40 days at Scott Base.

FIELD ACTIVITY

With only a short season available, effort was concentrated on the two large volcanic cones (Waesche and Sidley) in the south of the Executive Committee Range, with one very long "day-trip" post Mt Hartigan to Mt Cumming. We travelled immediately (23/24 December) from the "put-in" site SW of Waesche to a campsite on the southern moraine of Waesche itself, at 2000m. After nine days of day-trips from this camp we moved to another camp west of the caldera rim of Mt Sidley, at 2380m. Nineteen days were worked from this Sidley camp, including the Mt Cumming's trip, before returning to the put-in site (19 January) to wait for our aircraft. We left the area late on 24 January. Weather was continuously poor, but only two days were restricted to camp.

While we travelled from camp to camp with sledges linked to the skidoos, it proved ineffective to tow sledges to and from the outcrops each day. The volcanic slopes were too steep for this established technique. Instead we reconnoitred the outcrop routes with either a skidoo and sledge or two skidoos, and flagged the established route. Subsequent trips along the flagged line were then made by one or more machines independently, each machine carrying two personnel.

page 78

The likely fate of two persons on one machine if they break through a crevasse roof win be immediately obvious to anyone with relevant field experience. However, we felt that we kept this hazard at an acceptable level by checking and flagging the route, and by sticking to the flagged line. If this technique is anticipated, the level of experience of the party members must be such that the route which is accepted and flagged will be unquestionably safe.

FIELD OPERATION
Briefing - Christchurch

I personally left for Antarctica the morning after arrival in Christchurch from Mt Cook but I felt the Tekapo briefing and subsequent correspondence were sufficient.

Briefing - Scott Base

There were several briefings as time went by. It was unfortunate that we heard of the cancellation of K048 through American sources before the NZ operations officer and SENZREP were informed of the decision.

Clothing
Clothing has been getting steadily better over the years, a reflection on the experience of Antarctic Division staff. My comments here are really an indication of preferences:
1.Instead of a separate gaiter, build the gaiter into the salopette, like ski trousers.
2.Zips on pockets rather than velcro, and domes on flaps, not velcro.
3.Inner zip pockets for small items on vests, jackets.
4.A shorter neck gaiter, with elastic-taped seams.
5.Loopstitch sox with heels.
6.Contrasting colours on shell garments (not uniform blue) for photography.
7.The needs of field staff and of geology staff sometimes differ, particularly in gloves required.
Field Communications

K048 (US designation SO81B) used US field radios with no problems. We also used three GE handheld radios, mostly with success. For a remote field event, both types of radio are very useful.

Scott Base/Field Party Relationship

This was very good this season. Due, I believe, to more effective staffing levels and job descriptions at Scott Base which helped reduce stress. Also, to the selection of Scott

page 79

Base personnel. All members of K048 were very experienced in Antarctica, and we hope had no unreasonable expectations. Good relations were maintained with McMurdo BFC over the summer, and with the US snow-mobile mechanic.

Our thanks to all concerned for a safe and enjoyable time on the ice.

Bill Atkinson

MOUNTAIN GUIDE
page 96

Appendix 3: Location Map

Figure 10 Map of the Executive Committee Range.

Figure 10 Map of the Executive Committee Range.