Other formats

    Adobe Portable Document Format file (facsimile images)   TEI XML file   ePub eBook file  

Connect

    mail icontwitter iconBlogspot iconrss icon

Salient. Newspaper of Victoria University of Wellington Students Association. Vol 41 No. 5. March 27 1978

Trot Trade-off

Trot Trade-off

Dear Simon,

I wish to protest the unwarranted attack on me in the last issue of Salient Abusing your position as editor, you inserted some rather curious comments in a report of the SRC elections on my election to International Affairs Officer. You ask, "why did he risk a difficult election in a field not his own? To put it another way, was there a trade off?"

This comment inferred that:
1)I wasn't experienced in the International Affairs area of student politics and
2)I was party to some "trade off" — that is I participated in an unprincipled deal to ensure my election.

Both positions are absolutely false and it is a sorry comment on your own editorial approach that you should insert such unfounded opinions in another person's article.

I can only conclude that your support for the defeated candidate coloured your objectivity in considering what happened. For instance, you do not seem to have even listened to my election speech, where I explained that I was twice elected International Affairs Officer at Auckland University. In addition, while holding the positions of Welfare Vice-President and Resource Officer at Auckland, I was closely involved in International campaigns, particularly those concerned with Southern Africa and Overseas Students.

As to your accusation of a "trade off", this is no more than a rather shoddy innuendo. At no stage did I offer my support or otherwise to anyone if they supported me, nor did I ask for such a "trade off. In fact, your inference to that effect tells us more about your own approach to student politics than mine.

Yours,

Mike Treen

(If I can draw a distinction between "tradeoff and "jack-up", the fact remains that there was a convenient distribution of positions in which the three successful candidates (Sue Cairney in Education, Sean Tuohy in National and yourself in International) all supported each other. This surprised many people, and I take it no further than that. — Ed.)