Other formats

    Adobe Portable Document Format file (facsimile images)   TEI XML file   ePub eBook file  

Connect

    mail icontwitter iconBlogspot iconrss icon

Salient: An Organ of Student Opinion at Victoria College, Wellington, N.Z. Vol. 11, No. 11, September 22nd, 1948

[Introduction]

The 1948 contest was won by Otago at Massey on Saturday, September 11th. The best speaker was P. O'Connor from Otago who has twice previously won the award. Auckland was second in the teams contest with Victoria third, while K. O'Sullivan, of Auckland, and Jim Milburn were second and third placed speakers. It is interesting to note that the three speakers filling the three places were all second speakers in their teams. The speech that won P. O'Connor his award was brilliant and he deserved his placing.

Massey turned on excellent hospitality, and visitors are now in a better position to appreciate Professor Peren's dreams. The actual debating hall was better decorated than any other Joynt Scroll hall the writer has seen, with a massed ceiling high drape of all colleges colours, massed bowls of irises and individual iris plants in trays along the walls. Messrs. Oram, M.P. Opic and Murray were the judges. They commented on the very high standard although they were disappointed in all the debates except the one that produced the winning and second teams.

The 'first debate was affirmed by CUC aginst MAC on the subject, "That the press is (ailing in its duty to society."

This debate broke down and lost meaning because neither side attempted to define what the press's duty towards society was. This was noted by the judges who commented through their spokesman, Mr. Oram, that an analytic argument would have produced much better results. In the early stages there was considerable attention paid to the difference between reporting and editorials so perhaps it was inevitable that an interjector should interrupt the summing up of Mr. Bowron, the CUC leader when discussing magazines such as "Man" with the question, "hut have you read its editorials?" It was Mr. Bowron, too, who brought the house down by turning to the chairman and saying "if you were a man, sir."------long pause.