Minds Still At Work

On Thursday, 8th April, the Philosophical Society held its second meeting of the philosophical season in room C14, Weir House, Owing to the success of the previous meeting the room was crowded to the door—some were turned away. It was only by the operation of a shift system that the last man managed to get in, in time for supper. Seventeen members attended.

The subject for discussion was the distinction between science and philosophy. Unfortunately, I arrived a little too late to hear the introductory address by Mr. Robinson on Wolfenden (our text) and various topics of philosophical interest, but I am told on good authority that it was presented in an extremely lucid manner.

Mr. Robinson stringently criticized Mr. Wolfenden (in absentia) and brought forward new ideas on the proposed course of study. His proposal was to diverge from Mr. W.'s treatment and to deal with matters of a less metaphysical character. This suggestion was received with wild enthusiasm by Mr. Robinson's supporters who rose to their feet and cried "Down with Wolfenden," "Mr. Robinson for ever." and "Good old Erle."

Dress was quite informal and ever-one looked most attractive. Particularly were two ensembles I noticed—Arch. in a brown corduroy jacket, battle-dress style and Brian in a brushed-wool sweater of eau-de-nil which contrasted effectively with his platinum hair.

With reference to Science and Philosophy, a newcomer from Otago explained the probable attitude of Dingle-types (a major classification we believe). Dingle-types hold the fundamental tenet that the whole of existence will ultimately be explained away in terms of Physics. We hope for the sake of the club that this will not be too soon. There was an interesting discussion upon this issue.

Neil was wearing an impressionistic tie in subdued shades of green and white which was only rivalled by Harry's draught-board sweater.

Another topic approached was the implication of Descartes' "Cogito ergo sum." There was an interesting discussion upon this issue.

A member whose name I could not catch was wearing the most distinguished fairisle pullover that has yet been seen at the society's autumn meetings.

Part of the time was spent on a lengthy investigation of Hume's theory of Causation, illustrated by billiard balls. There was an interesting discussion upon this issue.

The girls made an engaging "tableau vivant" as they reclined on the bed. Most were in casual attire although one or two wore dresses. Corduroy seems to be popular among women as among men this year.

The welcome call of "Come and get it." brought us to supper. (Crockery by courtesy of the New Zealand Railways.)